Peyton Manning for MVP
Can a player win the MVP award without playing in a single game during the season? The award is supposed to be awarded to the Most Valuable Player and even with three quarterbacks breaking the 5,000 yard passing barrier this season, Peyton Manning is obviously the most valuable player in the NFL. In a league where the motto is, “next man up” the Indianapolis Colts played that way as much as John Elway actually believes in Tim Tebow.
The Colts had the same roster as they did the previous year with one exception…Peyton Manning. Last season the Colts were 10-6 and made the playoffs. This season they couldn’t even spell Playoffs. It’s as if the news of Peyton Manning’s neck surgery came out in the news and the city of Indianapolis were playing Jim Mora’s “Playoffs? You wanna talk about playoffs?” highlight on local television stations. They undoubtable didn’t have a chance at making the playoffs, but they should have had a fighting chance. The receivers, running backs and defense were still there so, why the 8 game swing? Manning was never in the backfield intercepting passes, or pass rushing the quarterback. He was simple the Colt’s General Patton directing his men on the field.
In Peyton Mannings 13 seasons, the Colts have won 10 or more games 11 times. They have won 10 or more games nine straight seasons. With Manning at quarterback the offense’s average rank in the NFL was sixth. Without Manning this past season they were ranked 28th. The defense’s average rank with Manning at quarterback was 9th and without him 30th. In the previous 13 seasons the Colts average margin of victory was 4.7 points. This season the average margin of victory of -11.7.
Football may be the ultimate team sport of America’s four major sports. No one man can take over a game like he can in basketball, baseball, or hockey; so why the huge difference with and without Peyton Manning? The Houston Texans were down to their 3rd string quarterback and still made the playoffs. The Bengals made it to the playoffs with a rookie quarterback and receiver. A team full of veteran players fall apart because Peyton Manning couldn’t play? If I were a Colts fan I wouldn’t know whether to call shenanigans or be embarrassed. I am waiting for Colts Owner Jim Irsay to finally say, “we knew we didn’t have a chance to win the Super Bowl this year, so why not take a dive this season for the greater good and future of this franchise. We got lucky in 1998 when we drafted Peyton, and this time we are drafting Standford QB Andrew Luck.”

